Although George and Lennie try to stop Carlson from shooting the dog, they are not ultimately successful. These words imply Candy's weakness for not putting the dog down; in addition, they foreshadow the final chapter of Steinbeck's novella as Lennie, who no longer can be of use and who has made one too many mistakes must go or be imprisoned. For entertainment, Lennie believed anything that George would say (gullible) The pranks stopped because Lennie almost drowned, Lennie needs George for survival. Finally, Carlson may have simply felt that it was the right thing to do. Accessed 1 May 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. What Are Carlsons Reasons For Shooting the Dog? Candy wants to get out of that place because he doesn't have the ability to do anything. The audience will also recognize it as Carlson's gun because a Luger is a very distinctive-looking automatic pistol. He made a naturalistic dramatic scene out of it. In the world Of Mice and Men describes, Candys dog represents the fate awaiting anyone who has outlived his or her purpose. Get him outa here, Candy! Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime. Additionally, Carlson believes that the dog is a threat because it might bite him or someone else. He relentlessly pursues the dogs death, more for his own comfort than to put the dog out of its misery. Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. He wrote a letter to the editor, praising the publication What is Old Susy's place? What is Carlsons solution to the problem of the dog? This causes Candy to become even more lonely and isolated. Share Cite. Wellhell! The exact reason is never mentioned. I wisht somebodyd shoot me if I got old an a cripple, Slim presents an important symbolism behind Candys old dog. Because of his condition, he is unable to work alongside the other men and in turn feels lonely with only his dog to accompany him which is later euthanized as a result of, [Candy] said miserably, "You seen what they done to my dog tonight? Like Candys dog, Lennie depends on George to take care of him and show him what to do. for a customized plan. Had him since he was a pup. eNotes Editorial, 25 Jan. 2014, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/outline-all-the-reasons-why-carlson-wants-to-455632. Want 100 or more? Curley punches Lennie in the face. Why do many critics find fault with Of Mice and Men? She does not like Curley, he cannot trust her, and she is not loyal. Candy was heartbroken when Carlson shot her dog. Candy's dog is a loyal companion that has been with him for . Candy replies that he has had the dog for too many years to kill it, but Carlson continues to pressure him. You'll also receive an email with the link. What are Carlsons reasons for shooting Candys dog quizlet? Simple repairs. Carlson completely ignores any sentimental or affectionate feelings Candy might have for his dog and only focuses on the dogs uselessness, suffering, and inconvenience. One thing he probably had in mind at the outset was that he wanted to end the story with one man killing his friend out of compassion. The author needed to establish that George had access Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. She was angry at the person who shot him and felt like she needed to take revenge. Quick Answer: Why Does Carlson Want To Shoot Candys Dog. "Carl's right, Candy. Subscribe now. He would only allow himself to do something; Lennie and the dog both need someone else to survive with and both grew up with either George or Candy when they were younger. Report your findings. I never been mad, an' I ain't now. This event is significant because it shows the contrast between Carlson and the other characters in the novel. He had his broom in his hand. They says he wasn't no good to himself nor nobody else(Steinbeck 60). Ostensibly, Candy lets Carlson kill his dog because he succumbs to pressure from all the men in the bunkhouse, including Slim; Candy is also afraid of losing his job if all the men were to complain about the smelly old dog. Lennie scares the girl in the red dress in the town of Weed. Members will be prompted to log in or create an account to redeem their group membership. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. However, it is important to note that not everyone in the novel is like Carlson. George decides to be the one to kill Lennie because he didnt want Lennie to suffer at the hands of Curley. How might this statement be an example of foreshadowing? It is old and can no longer walk, meaning that it is likely only going to get worse as time goes on. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? Afterwards, Candy has regrets about the ordeal, and wishes he would have killed the dog himself instead. Carlson is a heartless person who doesn't care about anyone but himself. Marie et Philippe /// travailler /// centre commercial. His only company is his faithful dog companion who later in the story is killed by Carlson. In Of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley's wife? The way the characters react towards the shooting of Candys dog reveals a lot abut the characters that we might not have expected. Explain the parallelism between the relationship $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% On a more symbolic level, Candy knows that shooting the dog would be like shooting himself. "Hes all stiff with rheumatism. Example: Curley stepped over to Lennie like a terrier. April 30, 2023, SNPLUSROCKS20 A ranch workers life during this time period was determined by his usefulness, and survival was directly linked to his ability to physically work. The book is written in such a way that it could obviously be adapted into a script with a minimum of time and trouble. Members will be prompted to log in or create an account to redeem their group membership. Second, Carlson says that the dog is no goodfor Candy. Here, Candy desperately tries to hold on to his old dog and escape Carlsons pressure to shoot him because he aint no good to himself. Candy explains his history with his dog, how he had him since he was a pup, and how he was the best damn sheep dog. Through Candys pleas, his dog symbolizes a connection to the past and the common desire to hold onto the best of the past. After Carlsons many pushes to have Candy shoot his old dog, Slim, the skinner, whose opinions were law, speaks up and agrees with Carlson, encouraging Candy to accept the old dogs fate. In the end, Candy is isolated due to his age and disability., An aging ranch handyman, Candy lost his hand in an accident and worries about his future on the ranch. Why is the man in the magazine? Any action you take based on the information found on nahf.org is strictly at your discretion. What are the advantages of rotary screen printing, compared to other methods? She loved that dog more than anything and couldn't believe that Carlson would do something like that. Did you know you can highlight text to take a note? Additionally, Carlson may have been worried about the dog being a burden on Candy. They says he wasnt no good to himself nor nobody else. Lennie mentions that she is pretty. The main reason why Carlsons killing of Candys dog was justified is because the old dog was well past its years and of no use to anyone. Candy loves his old companion and can't bear the thought of killing him, but Slim, surprisingly, sides with Carlson: he'd want to be shot if he were old and crippled. - All Animals Faq, Why Does Carlson Shoot Candy's Dog - All Animals Faq, Why Does Carlson Want To Shoot Candy's Dog - All Animals Faq. When Slim offers Candy a puppy and says of the old dog, That dog aint no good to himself. Carlson explains to Candy exactly why the old dog should be put out of its misery. How do the descriptions of Curley change throughout the fight? However, their attempt to stop Carlson shows that they are not like him. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! As Carlson describes Candys dog as so God damn old he cant hardly walk and that he [s]tinks like hell, too, Carlson is trying to convince Slim to agree with him and persuade Candy to shoot his old dog. Through this description, Candys dog symbolizes how old age and decline are viewed by the ranch workers of this time period. Carlson believes the dog is too old and decrepit to be of any use. The bus driver lies to George and Lennie. He was killed with far greater compassion though., Carlson killing Candys dog leaves Candy wishing hed done it himself, whereas when George killed Lennie, he isnt left with guilt. Both George and Lennie already have conflict with Curley. He also observes how Candy works the mechanism when he cleans the weapon after using it on the dog. What is Slim's response? One possibility is that Carlson was simply trying to be a good steward of the ranch and saw the dog as a threat to the livestock. When she confronted him about it, he claimed that the dog was "just a nuisance" and that he "had to shoot it." By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. First, the dog is "stiff with rheumatism." Candy is reluctant to have his dog killed, but Carlson argues that the dog is in pain and that it would be better for the animal to be put out of its misery. Lennie catches Curley's next punch in his massive paw and crushes down on his hand. What is the name of the town from which George and Lennie are fleeing when the story opens? Purchasing All information published on this website is provided in good faith and for general use only. It was an unusual-looking pistol because it was a German Luger. I wisht somebody'd shoot me if I got old an' a cripple.". Dont have an account? He seemed to shake himself free for speech. He is rejected by the people of the ranch due to him being old and handicapped. Disappointed in her life, Curley's wife wonders where she would be if she had become, How are George and Lennie different from the other men, In the power structure of the ranch which character has the least amount of power. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. It is complicated. Please wait while we process your payment. What does Carlson killing Candys dog symbolize? Candy had to agree to let Carlson shoot his old dog because the author mandated it for plot purposes. Lennie killed it by snapping its neck because he thought the puppy was going to bite him. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Candy was clearly attached to his dog and was devastated by its death. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? How does Lennie respond? Carlson explains to Candy exactly why the old dog should be put out of its misery. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. for a group? Why? ). $24.99 It gets them more excited to go to work and keeps them going. Candys loneliness affects George and Lennie and alters the dream to a three man thing instead of just George and Lennie., The Significance of the Killing of Candy's Dog in Of Mice and Men. Example: Lennie covered his face with his huge paws and bleated with terror. Steinbeck could have had Carlson just show George the gun and explain how the automatic worked, but he was too conscientious a writer for such shortcuts. After shooting the dog, Carlson cleans the gun carefully. Carlson goes on to elaborate on the dog's smell stating that he can tells the dog has been in the bunk house for days after because the bunk house stinks for two to three days. I ain't mad. Through these characters, Steinbeck helps the reader understand the stereotype of the uselessness of the elderly and disabled. The "shotgun ending" of the story brings it to a conclusion; otherwise a story about the hard lives of farm workers could go on indefinitely. More books than SparkNotes. After George, Lennie, and Candy make a pact not to tell anyone about their dream, Candy makes the following statement: "I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. (one code per order). Contact us Then, Candy doesn't want Carlson to shoot his dog because it's his only companion. There is no investigation or interrogation. Everybody thinks it was Lennie who stole the Luger after he killed Curley's wife and fled from the ranch. That allows the story, and the play, to end cleanly. George even tries to reason with Carlson, explaining that the dog is old and helpless, but Carlson does not listen. Candy is reluctant to have his dog killed, but Carlson argues that the dog is in pain and that it would be better for the animal to be put out of its misery. What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? Why not? We go in to old Susy's place. Stinks like hell, too. Candy is reluctant to have his dog killed, but Carlson argues that the dog is in pain and that it would be better for the animal to be put out of its misery. The dog is mean and tried to bite him. Get him outa here, Candy! At the same time, the concept of shooting something to save it from a miserable life foreshadows the tragic events that will unfold between George and Lennie at the end of the story. Related Read: Does lazy dog have a dog menu? Trace the parallels between the relationships of Candy and his dog and George and Lennie. Candy virtually has no choice but to let the dog go because he would be shunned by the men and Carlson would continue to badger him, and then probably act on his own, anyway. Candys dog wasn't in good health and Lennie killed Curly's wife and would be in trouble with the law. MARIA: Quieres 4\underline{\hspace{10pt}4\hspace{10pt}}4 al bsquetbol? Worse than the dog parallel, though, is that Candy (unlike his dog) is emotionally broken by this whole affair. And the silence lasted." (pg.48) Why does the image of silence play an important role at this point in the novel? Carlson was looking out for Candys dog and didnt want him to suffer any longer, so did a horrible act so that Candy didnt have to. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. An' I got fifty more saved up right in the bank right now. FOUND ON http://www.easynotecards.com/notecard_set/2232. What is Carlsons problem with Candys dog? There are a number of possible reasons why Carlson might have shot Candy's dog. Along with this, Candy and his dog create a parallel with George and Lennie., Candy is isolated after the loss of his hand since he is no longer able to work in the field with the other men. George feels that he can trust Slim. When they arrive at the ranch, Lennie and George meet Candy and his elderly dog as they are introduced to the others in the bunkhouse. Candy says that he should have shot the dog, and that "you shoot your own dog.". Carlson shoots Candy's dog because it is old, sick, and no longer able to work as a sheep dog. By the way he acts towards other characters in the novella. Why does Carlson shoot Candys dog? One of the new people that Lennie and George meet was Candy and his old dog. As Carlson describes Candys dog as so God damn old he cant hardly walk and that he [s]tinks like hell, too, Carlson is trying to convince Slim to agree with him and persuade Candy to shoot his old dog. Through this description, Candys dog symbolizes how old age and decline are viewed by the ranch workers of this time period. Related Read: What to do my dog killed my other dog? Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Ill have thirty dollars more comin, time you guys is ready to quit.. Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. The ending puts a "frame" around the story. I don't know nothing that stinks as bad as an old dog. Candy does not wish to defy Slim, due to his authority above the rest. "That stink hangs around even after he's gone." How does his statement add to the violent nature of the novel? How are Lennie's actions similar to the events that happened earlier when Lennie and George were. On page 44, the men are discussing Candys dog in the bunkhouse. Lennie, who is still dreaming about the rabbits, also smiles, which leads Curley to confront him aggressively. What excites Lennie most about his dream life with George? Which of the following characters check the dead body for vital signs? He has nothing to look forward to and nothing in his life, this dream gives him something to live for and look forward to, Spanish 2 Vocabulary Quiz 8 PS on Las Fiestas, Spanish 2 Vocabulary Quiz 9 PS on Las Celebra, A Tale of Two Cities: Book 2 Study Questions, The tale of two cities book 1 and beg of 2, PFL Unit 2B Summative Assessment Study Guide, PFL Unit 2 Summative Assessment Study Guide, SpringBoard English Language Arts: Grade 10, myPerspectives: English Language Arts, Grade 7, Vocabulary for Achievement: Fourth Course, myPerspectives: Grade 10, Volume 2 California Edition, Social processes, Attitudes and Behavior, Cul. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. There are other characters, such as George and Lennie, who are much more compassionate and caring. I herded sheep with him. He said proudly, You wouldnt think it to look at him now, but he was the best damn sheep dog I ever seen., Here, Candy desperately tries to hold on to his old dog and escape Carlsons pressure to shoot him because he aint no good to himself. Candy explains his history with his dog, how he had him since he was a pup, and how he was the best damn sheep dog. Through Candys pleas, his dog symbolizes a connection to the past and the common desire to hold onto the best of the past. Both of these instances where Carlson kills Candys dog and George kills Lennie, supports the theme of loyalty and friendship. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. After his dog was shot, it was almost described as if it was Candy that got shot. She knew that Carlson was not telling her the whole truth and that he was just trying to make himself feel better. The silence came into the room. As the dog was being executed, Candy laid in bed and stayed silent. Was Carlson killing Candys dog justified? Everything that happens happens because the author decided to make it happen. Throughout the fight there are many animals references referring to either Lennie or Curley. Related Read: Why is my dog eating frozen dog poop? How does that seem, given, The dog ( represents George and Lennie's friendship ) is all that he has and grew up with. ), Where does Whit invite George and Lennie to go? He is a terrible person and Candy's dog deserved better. "God awmighty, that dog stinks. Carlson knew that Candy loved that dog, and he knew how much she would miss it. You come for me, an' I'll kick your ******** head off.". Why does George lie about the gun? Candy suggests doing this because the dog is old, smells, and is crippled. Lennie is given the imagery of a large bear-like creature who can, if allowed to, kill the little "terrier" dog. Carlson is a middle-aged man. Wed love to have you back! He is an outcast and is discriminated against. on 50-99 accounts. Candy realizes that his fate is to be put on the roadside as soon as hes no longer useful; on the ranch, he wont be treated any differently than his dog. And at his heels there walked a dragfooted sheep dog, gray of muzzle, and with pale, blind old eyes. By the time Lennie finally relaxes his grip, Curley's hand has been ruined. An he aint no good to himself. After this scene, Candy finally lets Carlson euthanize his dog. When he shoots Candy's dog, it is clear that he does not care about the animal's life, or Candy's feelings. Candy says that he has had the dog far too long to put it down until Slim joins in, saying, In the world of Of Mice and Men, Candys dog represents the fate awaiting anyone who has outlived his or her purpose. Construct a garment that has a collar, sleeves, and pockets. Candy probably owned a dog for the same reason that Carlson owned a pistol. Describe the nature of the argument between Curley and Slim. Carlson says that he will shoot Candys dog in the back of the neck where the neck and head meet. The other men are not scared of Curley. Candy and his dog parallel the relationship of George and Lennie. Curley returns with Whit, Carlson and Slim. Look at several garments in different price ranges in a store. First, the dog is "stiff with rheumatism.". Whit enters the bunkhouse with a magazine featuring a man he used to work with. what happen that made george stop playing tricks on lennie? Lennie was attracted to the same type of girl in Weed. Why do dogs lay down when they see another dog? The dream they share gives them something to help them survive. Why does Carlson insist on shooting Candy's dog? Carlson is a bitter man. Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. You'll also receive an email with the link. George and Lennie, who remain behind, begin to discuss their future farm. Charleston insists that candy puts the dog down because it is far too old and it is suffering. One possible reason may be that Candy is fearful of losing his job if the men in the bunkhouse got angry about the smelly old dog. In John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men, who actually steals Carlson's gun? Lennie does not immediately fight back, instead crying and calling to George for help. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. He pressured Candy into putting the dog out of his misery and evidentially shot the dog himself. He is an old man that is missing a hand. If George had not killed Lennie, he knew someone else would in a more painful way. You'll be billed after your free trial ends. Carlson wants to shoot Candy's old dog because it irritates him. And Slim gave him none. Related Read: Why does my dog bite my other dogs neck? While this may have been true, it was clearly not the whole story. The dog struggled lamely to the side of the room and lay down, grunting softly to himself and licking his grizzled, moth-eaten coat. Slim asks Carlson to take a shovel with him when he goes to shoot Candy's dog because he was being careful and understanding towards Candy's dog's death. Discount, Discount Code Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? Carlson feels that this was the best thing for the dog. This factor challenged Candy to fit in with the other men. You can argue that his reasons are partly good and partly just selfish and mean. Explain some similarities between Candy and his dog and George and Lennie in Of Mice and Men. That dog aint no good to himself. The killing of Candys dog foreshadows Lennies death. Candy was an old, One of the first people George and Lennie meet is Candy, an old man who is missing his right hand due to an accident at the ranch. If you don't see it, please check your spam folder. The author needed to establish that George had access to a weapon, but it could not be a weapon that George actually owned. Ultimately, Candy has littlechoice but to free the dog because Carlson is continuing to aggressively push him and there is potential for further harm. Although Carlson promises to kill the dog painlessly, his insistence that the old animal must die supports a cruel natural law that the strong will dispose of the weak. He thinks that Slim is with his wife. Save over 50% with a SparkNotes PLUS Annual Plan! The weapon George uses to kill Lennie had to be a pistol because George had to keep it concealed. What type of establishment is it? He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. He cant bring himself to shoot his pet himself, and we suspect this is going to be the same fear that keeps him from making anything more of his life. It was dangerous to be riding on freight cars with strangers, dangerous to be sleeping in hobo jungles, dangerous to be tramping the highways, and dangerous to own anything of value. Explain some similarities between Candy and his dog and George and Lennie in Of Mice and Men. TO CANCEL YOUR SUBSCRIPTION AND AVOID BEING CHARGED, YOU MUST CANCEL BEFORE THE END OF THE FREE TRIAL PERIOD. Lennie's first impulse is to kill the cats, just as Carlson's is to shoot Candy's dog. Carlson shoots the dog, and a while later, Candy tells George : "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. Ultimately, Candy agrees to Carlson's request, and the dog . Curley flops like a fish. Got no teeth, damn near blind, cant eat.[]. She had raised him from a pup and he was her best friend. Although Curley is the boss's son, they refuse to let Curley physically intimidate them. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% They had to run away from Weed because Lennie would not let go of a pretty girl. He didn't want to shoot his dog because of that reason too. Project. Carlson says the dog "ain't no good" to Candy, unable to see that the dog still has value as Candy's friend and companion. "You ******** punk," he said. Carlson wanted to shoot Candys dog because it was smelly, but mainly because it was old, toothless, and overall in a miserable physical state, and Carlson wanted to put it out of its misery. George probably kept Lennie as a buddy for protection as well as for companionship. SparkNotes PLUS For example, he was only close to his dog before he met George and Lennie and he was so eager to meet them and make friends. What does Curley wear to set himself apart from the other men? Discuss why people purchase counterfeit goods and the impact this has on legal manufacturers. You're yella as a frog belly. Already a member? Slim read, "'Yours for success, William Tenner.'"